Artisanal wooden jigsaw puzzles. Made in the USA. FREE USA shipping.
Cart 0
Hoefnagel Puzzle Club Subscription

Hoefnagel Puzzle Club Subscription

$ 202.00
Free Shipping

Like old-school Netflix, but for wooden jigsaw puzzles:

This is a subscription to the Hoefnagel Wooden Jigsaw Puzzle Club, which is a nation-wide private library by mail of over 1,500 different wooden jigsaw puzzles by over 50 different wooden jigsaw puzzle makers, including most Artifact/Ecru puzzles, but also fancy-schmancy hand-cut puzzles by the best puzzle-makers in the world like Stave puzzles, as well as laser-cut puzzles from around the world like Wentworth Puzzles from England and Mr. Bob Puzzles from Australia. 

You can browse the library before joining to see what all we offer.

Here's how the Hoefnagel Club works:
  • You add any puzzles you'd like to do to your wishlist (most puzzles come in a pack with two puzzles). 
  • You can keep each pack as short or as long as you want (until the membership expires).
  • After you return a pack, we send you a new pack from your wishlist, usually in about a week. 

You can go through puzzles as fast or slow as you want, but for each pack you ship out, we charge a $9.95 shipping fee (shipping to you is free).   Most packs have 2 puzzles, so this is generally $5 total-shipping-costs per puzzle. 

Is The Club A Good Value? Yes if you do at least 1 puzzle-a-month. If you do fewer puzzles, this is still an amazing value if you want access to the world's best puzzles. 

What Do Members Say About It? Scroll down to read customer reviews to see what actual members have to say.

What If Something Goes Wrong? We aim to provide a hassle-free, high-quality experience, and have excellent customer service to fix any problems with puzzles or shipping. Email us at with any specific concerns or questions.

Makes a Great Gift!: You can gift a subscription in two ways.  

Option 1: Just the Membership: Buy the membership here (and let them pay their own ship-out fees), then email us right away at to let us know it is a gift with:

  • when you want them notified by email (and the subscription activated)
  • their email address
  • your gift message (any length)

    Option 2: All Expenses Paid: If you prefer to cover all the shipping fees for your gift, buy your gift subscription from the Hoefnagel Puzzle Club page directly, they will keep your credit card on file and charge it for your recipient's shipping fees. Note some people go through a pack a week, so please make sure you love them that much before choosing this option! 

    What Happens Next? If you purchase your membership here, you will receive an email in ~24 hours with instructions for activating your subscription, and you'll receive your first puzzle pack 2-10 days after activation.  

    More Questions? Please see the FAQ at

    More from this collection

    Write a Review

    Name: Anna
    Review: I absolutely love this puzzle club. By my rough calculation I have done over $3000 worth of puzzles in the first year. It is completely worth it, because I never would’ve paid that amount of money to buy puzzles. I have dozens on my wish list because there are so many that I like and so I’m always pleased with whatever shows up! When I have had a problem like a lost piece, it has been very fast and pleasant to resolve. If you want to do a lot of high quality, beautiful wooden puzzles, this totally the way to do it. I just renewed for my second year and I can’t wait to do more!
    Name: Janet Farnham
    Review: Everything about this rental club has been superb! First, it has allowed me to try many types of puzzles, cuts, makers, styles, etc. The world of wooden jigsaw puzzles is so unlike cardboard: there are many different designs and shapes. Before I heard about the Club, I was buying from different makers only to find some that just were not right for me. Hoefnagel has saved me so much money in the process of learning. And the customer service is excellent: Maya and Mysti seem more like friends than business people. Anyone who loves wooden jigsaw puzzles or wants to learn about them will find this Club a fabulous resource!
    Name: Barb
    Review: Absolutely love this club. What a great idea for people that love doing puzzles but don’t want to buy brand new. The selection is excellent and it is so fun to get a pack in the mail. Customer service is prompt and every effort is made to satisfy the customer.
    Name: Michael Brandt
    Review: This is a great service. I became addicted to wooden puzzles nearly a decade ago and started buying them several times year and letting those people that needed to know what my preferred birthday/Christmas gifts were. But…they’re not cheap and after some years went by shelf space began to become a concern. But with this club price and space became of little concern and I joined in November 2021. Now I’ve just (9-1-22) finished my 100th puzzle in a bit less than 10 months. There is such a wide selection now that all preferences for difficulty and/or subject matter can be accommodated. I’ve done them in solving times ranging from 48 minutes to 23 hours. I had a wishlist of over 50 when I started and new offerings appear at such a rate that I still have about 40, so perhaps if I keep the same solving rate I will run out of interesting things eventually but it will be many years yet before that happens. I can’t imagine anyone who enjoys puzzle solving being less than thrilled by being a member. It’s like being in a perpetual state of pre-birthday/Christmas anticipation. The mechanics of receiving and dispatching the puzzles is virtually effortless.
    Name: Joy
    Review: This is easily the best subscription/membership that I’ve ever had. The wooden puzzles are fun, beautiful, and very high quality. Each piece is a miniature work of art. Amazing selection—options for every difficulty level and visual taste. With priority mail, I’ve received new shipments within a few days. In my first month of membership, I borrowed puzzles that would retail for over $450. So far, all puzzles have arrived in good condition and with no missing pieces.

    Share this Product